September 24th 2008 Posted in
android
Okay, I own an iPhone but I am interested in Google’s Android OS and the phones that will come out with that operating system on it… Just thought I’d take a look feature by feature and see how we stand…

2.Apps
Both platforms promise tons of applications, both platforms promise to deliver them wirelessly via online stores. The difference here lies in the “open” system versus the moderated system that Apple currently has, where they supposedly hand-review each item before approving it for Apple store use. Also, Apple is renowned for helping developers improve their code before release date. Some would say that an open environment is better, but I have to beg to differ. There is already so much crap on the iTunes App store and it is getting in the way of finding the gems that are there. Apple also tries to make sure that no malicious code makes it into any app store application, and also apparently has a fail safe to remotely stop malicious apps in their tracks. Time will tell on this point, and we will see whether the “free for all” Google store will be better than the moderated Apple app store… so since it is unfair to judge Google’s store before its release, I have to give this one a tie.
Winner: As of right now, Apple. But I am calling it a TIE to give Google a chance to release the store before we judge it. It might kick ass!
3.Keyboard
This one is a toughie, I was annoyed at the iPhone’s onscreen keyboard until I actually used it. Now I realize that the auto correct feature actually works pretty well and I can type almost as fast as I can on my laptop. The Android phones featured so far have pull out keyboards, which in my own personal experience are just another plastic made in China piece of hardware that will eventually break on you. This one is personal preference, and my own personal preference before using the multi-touch keyboard WAS a physical keyboard and I changed my mind quite quickly. I have to give this one a tie as it lies in personal preference, and even then… my own preference leaned towards the onscreen keyboard as it removed a lot of little plastic pieces and hardware that could fuck up… the iPhone has no keyboard and therefore no keyboard failures are possible. I split coffee on a crackberry once, no more keyboard functioning… did it on my iPhone too… keyboard still works…
Winner: Tie.
4.Flash
Although Android fanboys claim Android will have flash, I don’t see it mentioned ANYWHERE as being a reality. Neither platform has flash, and Steve Jobs himself said there was no flash on the iphone because the hardware couldn’t handle full flash and they did’t want a crippled flash that might or might not play flash correctly.
Winner: Tie (Neither)
5. Format Support
The iPhone supports viewing of many document formats, the Android will probably be restricted by the same licensing issues that plague iPhone, so who knows when you will be able to open and edit excel and word files on either?
Winner: Tie
6. PUSH Apps
Apps that can “push” information to your phone. As of currently, the iPhone doesn’t have any 3rd party apps that push info to your phone (My Facebook app wont automatically update it’s Messages in your inbox number on the icon until I actually open it and connect)… Soon though many apps will be able to do this on the iPhone. Nothing is promised yet for Android. As of now, Email, Contacts and Bookmarks from my Safari are pushed directly to my phone within 15 minutes or less of me typing them into my home computer (and vice versa)… Within 5 minutes of activating my new iPhone, I had all my contacts, email and bookmarks wirelessly synced to my iPhone before I left the shopping mall.
Winner: iPhone.
7.Variety Of Phones
Google Android will be available on many phones. Though variety is nice, the lack of standards for hardware makes it impossible for an app developer to count on the fact that a phone has a joystick, or an accelerometer,, or even bluetooth…which will probably make app developers make apps geared towards the lowest common denominator.. I mean, would you make an app that was usable by only 20% of Android phones (which had an acceleromoter or multitouch) or for 100% of Android phones? The iPhone’s standard hardware makes it so that all apps work on all iPhones. At the same time, Apple is known for adding more and more features and I’m sure the 3rd Generation iPhones will have hardware that will make some of the newer apps not compatible with the first 2 iterations of the iPhone. At the same time,the fact that there are multiple manufacturers making different Android phones with different hardware (hopefully a good mp3 player and a headphone jack will appear in future models) gives the advantage clearly to Android…more competition, more variety is good.
Winner: Android
Source and credit: supermanred.com